Call Us Today

Which Kind of Roof is Better? Metal Roofs vs. Shingles

When choosing a new roof for your Woodstock, GA,  home, it's challenging to decide on the right roofing material. Which is better, a metal roof or asphalt shingles

Shingles are a favorite because they are affordable and easy to install. They come in a variety of styles and colors, allowing you to customize the look of your home easily. On the other hand, metal roofing, which includes large panels made of steel, aluminum, tin, or copper, is more durable and resistant to extreme weather.

Differences between roofing materials can affect cost, longevity, maintenance, and the energy efficiency of your roof. When comparing metal roofs vs. shingles, metal roofs may cost more upfront than asphalt shingles, but their extended lifespan can save money in the long run. Paying attention to these factors will help to ensure you choose the right roof for your home.

Choosing the Right Roof

When selecting a roofing material, consider how various factors such as climate, durability, aesthetics, and costs affect your choice.

Climate and Weather Resistance

  • Metal Roofs: Ideal for areas that are prone to severe weather, such as Atlanta, GA, metal roofs are very resistant to high winds, hail, and fire. They also reflect heat, making them a good choice in hot climates.
  • Asphalt Shingles: While they provide good protection for your home, they may not perform as well as metal in severe weather. Certain types of shingles are designed to resist high winds and hail.

Roof Longevity and Durability

  • Metal Roofs: Typically last a long time, sometimes 40-70 years. They don't require much maintenance, either. Because of this, a metal roof can increase a property's value.
  • Asphalt Shingles: Less long-lived, ranging from 15 to 30 years. They typically need frequent repairs and maintenance, driving up costs over time.

Aesthetics and Design Variability

  • Metal Roofs: Can be installed in a variety of colors and styles. Metal roofing can suit many different home designs, improving curb appeal.
  • Asphalt Shingles: Also have a wide variety to choose from, allowing you to choose a roofing type that looks fabulous on your home.

Roofing Costs and Budget

  • Metal Roofs: Usually more expensive upfront. Materials and labor are both costly. The good news is that their longevity and low maintenance can offset your initial investment.
  • Asphalt Shingles: More affordable upfront with lower installation costs. The long-term maintenance, shorter lifespan, and reduced energy efficiency can easily reverse those savings over the years.

Pros and Cons of Metal Roofs

If you're thinking about installing a metal roof, you'll want to think about the balance between short and long-term costs, as well as your own needs and aesthetic preferences.

Energy Savings and Eco-friendliness

Metal roofing systems offer significant energy savings due to their reflective properties, which reduce the cost of cooling in hot weather. They are often made from high-quality, recyclable materials, making them more eco-friendly than traditional shingles.

  • Reflective coatings lead to lower energy costs.
  • Eco-friendly: Uses a high percentage of recycled materials.

Longevity and Maintenance

Possibly the most well-known perk of metal roofs is their longer lifespan. As long as they are well maintained, these roofs can last well over 50 years. Metal roofs don't need as much maintenance as traditional roofing materials, but they still should be inspected regularly to catch potential issues before they escalate.

  • Longevity: Can last 2-3 times longer than asphalt shingles.
  • Maintenance: Minimal, but regular inspections are recommended.

Cost Comparison

Metal roofing costs are higher upfront in comparison to asphalt shingles. Over time, the durability and minimal maintenance needs add up to substantial savings.

  • Initial Cost: Higher than asphalt shingles.
  • Long-Term Value: Potential savings due to less frequent replacement and repairs.

Installation and Repair

Metal roofing installation can be complex, a task to tackle by experienced professionals with metal roofing systems. Repairs are seldom needed, but when they are, they can be more complicated than shingle roofs.

  • Installation: Requires skilled professionals for proper fitting.
  • Repair: Less frequent, but may need specialized knowledge.

Pros and Cons of Asphalt Shingles

Asphalt shingles are the classic choice for a reason - they balance affordability with a wide range of aesthetic options. However, to make an informed decision, it's important to understand both their strengths and weaknesses.

Affordability and Accessibility

Asphalt shingle roofs are popular for their affordability. The material costs and labor costs are generally lower compared to other roofing options. Given that putting on a new roof is one of the most significant investments homeowners will face, this is a very important factor.

  • Material costs: Generally lower than metal roofing.
  • Labor costs: Less expensive - requires less specialized knowledge to install.

Ease of Installation

Asphalt shingles are straightforward to install. Most roofing contractors are familiar with shingle roofs, ensuring you can easily find skilled labor without having to pay a premium. Three-tab shingles, a common type of asphalt shingle, are especially well known for their ease of installation.

  • Installation time: faster than many other roofing materials.
  • Ease of installation: contributes to less costly labor 

Design and Color Options

With asphalt shingles, you're offered a variety of colors and styles that can match the aesthetic of your home. From the classic three-tab shingles to architectural styles, asphalt roofing can enhance your home's curb appeal.

  • A variety of colors are available to match different home styles.
  • Diverse designs, including three-tab and architectural shingles.

Life Span and Maintenance

While asphalt shingle roofs can be cost-effective initially, they do have a shorter lifespan than metal roofs, typically requiring replacement after 15 to 30 years. They require regular maintenance to maximize their lifespan and ensure protection against the elements.

  • Expected lifespan: 15 to 30 years, which is shorter compared to metal roofing.
  • Maintenance: Regular inspections and maintenance are crucial for longevity.

Types of Metal Roofs and Shingles

When choosing between metal roofs vs. shingles, the variety within each category is extensive. Your selection can significantly impact the appearance, durability, and cost of your roof.

Metal Roof Varieties

Steel Roof: Steel is a popular metal roofing material, often coated with zinc or a mixture of zinc and aluminum to prevent corrosion. It is affordable, recyclable, and comes in different types:

  • Galvanized Steel: Dipped in zinc to resist corrosion.
  • Galvalume Steel: Coated with a blend of aluminum, zinc, and silicon for enhanced protection.

Standing Seam Metal Roof: Recognized for its long, sleek panels that have raised seams. It is exemplary for its durability and resistance to water intrusion.

Metal Shingles: If you appreciate the look of traditional shingles but want the benefits of metal, metal shingles are your ideal choice. They mimic the appearance of wood shakes or architectural shingles yet provide the longevity and strength of metal.

Type of Metal:

  • Aluminum: Lightweight, resistant to corrosion, and suitable for coastal areas.
  • Copper: Long-lasting with a distinctive appearance that develops a greenish patina over time.
  • Tin: Rarely used today, but was traditionally used for long-lasting roof protection.

Shingle Types and Materials

Architectural Shingles: These are high-quality asphalt shingles, designed to resemble natural materials like slate or cedar shakes. They're thicker than standard asphalt shingles, giving a multi-dimensional appearance.

Cedar Shakes: Made from natural cedar, these shingles offer a rustic aesthetic and blend seamlessly with natural surroundings. Cedar is naturally resistant to insects but requires regular maintenance.

Wood Shakes: Similar to cedar, wood shakes come from a variety of woods and provide an authentic, timeless look. They're durable but require treatment to resist moisture and decay.

Asphalt Shingles: The most common shingle type found in residential buildings, they are cost-effective and come in various styles and colors. Their life expectancy isn't as long as metal options, but they are easier to install and repair.

Installation Process Analysis

When you decide to get a new roof, understanding the installation process can help you prepare for what's to come. Both metal roofs vs. shingles and asphalt shingle roofs have distinct steps in their installation processes that are important to know.

Preparing for a New Roof

Before a roofing contractor begins installation, they must remove your old roof. The process involves peeling off old shingles or metal panels and stripping the roof to the decking. When comparing metal roofs vs. shingles, you can expect a thorough inspection of the existing roof structure to identify any damage or areas that need repair. Accurate measurements of your roof will be taken, typically in square feet, to ensure that the correct amount of materials is ordered.

Steps in Metal Roof Installation

  1. Roof Decking Preparation: Your roofing contractor ensures the roof decking is sound and secure. Any necessary repairs or replacements are made at this stage.
  2. Underlayment Installation: A water-resistant or waterproof underlayment is laid over the decking, which acts as an additional barrier against the elements.
  3. Metal Panel Cutting and Shaping: Each panel is cut to the exact size needed for your roof's dimensions.
  4. Panel Attachment: Starting from the edge, metal panels are secured to the roof using screws or clips, overlapping each piece to create a watertight seal.

Asphalt Shingle Roof Installation Stages

  1. Deck Preparation: Just like with metal roofing, the decking must be inspected and prepared, which can include laying down a layer of felt paper.
  2. Shingle Placement: Shingles are laid from the bottom edge of the roof upward, with each row overlapping the last to shed water effectively.
  3. Flashing and Sealing: Different types of flashing are applied around roof features, and seals are created to prevent water penetration.

Remember, whether you choose metal panels or asphalt shingles, the installation process is critical to the overall longevity and performance of your new roof.

Cost Considerations for Roofing Materials

When deciding between metal roofs vs. shingles and shingle roofs, you must weigh initial expenses against potential long-term savings. The costs you encounter include those for materials, labor, and possible changes in insurance premiums.

Initial Investment vs. Long-Term Savings

Metal Roofs:

  • Initial Cost: You can expect your upfront investment for a metal roof to be around $13,200.
  • Long-Term Savings: Metal roofs are renowned for their durability, often lasting 40-70 years, which may lead to long-term financial savings.

Shingle Roofs:

  • Initial Cost: A typical asphalt shingle roof might cost approximately $8,500.
  • Long-Term Savings: Although less expensive initially, shingle roofs typically have a shorter lifespan, about 15-30 years, resulting in potential additional costs from replacements.

Material and Labor Cost Breakdown

Material Costs:

  • Metal Roofing: The material cost for metal roofs can range significantly based on the metal type, with options like aluminum, steel, copper, and zinc.
  • Shingle Roofing: Asphalt shingles are comparatively less expensive per square foot.

Labor Costs:

  • Metal Roofing: Installation costs for metal roofing are typically higher due to the specialized skills required for installation.
  • Shingle Roofing: Shingle roofs generally offer more straightforward and quicker installation, leading to lower labor costs.

Example Costs per Square Foot (approximate):

  • Metal Roofing: $5 - $14 (material) + $5 - $12 (labor)
  • Shingle Roofing: $1 - $4 (material) + $3 - $7 (labor)

Impact on Insurance Premiums

Metal Roofs:

  • Metal roofs may lead to lower insurance premiums over time due to their resistance to fire, wind, and hail, potentially saving you money annually on your insurance costs.

Shingle Roofs:

  • While the initial lower cost of shingle roofs can be appealing, insurers might not offer the same premium discounts, which could lead to higher annual insurance costs compared to metal roofs.

Environmental Impact and Energy Efficiency

When choosing between metal roofing and shingles, metal roofs vs. shingles, you'll find that both have unique environmental impacts and energy-saving potentials. Each material's efficiency and sustainability in practice and development come with varied advantages.

Sustainable Roofing Practices

Metal Roofing: You'll be choosing a more environmentally sustainable option with metal roofing, as it is commonly fabricated from recycled materials and is fully recyclable at the end of its lifespan. Unlike asphalt shingles, which contribute significantly to landfill waste, your choice of metal can reduce the environmental footprint associated with roofing materials.

Asphalt Shingles: While less sustainable than metal, advancements are being made. Some shingles can be recycled into paving materials, but the rate of recycling and availability is not as comprehensive as with metal materials.

Energy Efficiency of Materials

Metal Roofs: These roofs are highly reflective, leading to significant energy savings. You can expect a metal roof to reflect the sun’s heat rather than absorb it, which may result in up to a 50% reduction in energy costs. On a hot day, the surface of a metal roof can be about 100 degrees cooler than that of traditional shingle roofs.

Asphalt Shingles: Generally, they absorb more heat and are less energy-efficient compared to metal options. However, there are energy-efficient shingles that come with reflective coatings to mitigate this effect, they just typically do not match the efficiency of metal roofs.

Compatibility with Solar Panels

Metal Roofing:

  • Easy Integration: Installing solar panels on metal roofing is often easier due to the durability and strength of the material.
  • Fire Resistance: Metal roofs are inherently fire resistant, which complements the safety aspect when you install solar panels.

Asphalt Shingles:

  • Installation Considerations: You might find that shingle roofs require more careful handling when fitting solar panels to avoid damage.
  • Heat Absorption: The additional heat absorbed by shingle roofs can slightly decrease the efficiency of solar panels as they operate best in cooler conditions.

By understanding these aspects, you can make an informed decision for your roof that aligns with your environmental values and energy efficiency goals.

Weather Resistance and Structural Considerations

When deciding between metal roofing and asphalt shingles, consider how each option, metal roofs vs. shingles, responds to various weather conditions. It's important to assess their adaptability and resilience to ensure the longevity of your roof.

Metal Roofs in Harsh Climates

Metal roofs excel in environments where harsh weather is a common occurrence. Their durability makes them an outstanding choice for areas prone to high winds and heavy rain. Specifically, metal roofing can withstand wind gusts that often exceed 140 miles per hour. Moreover, metal roofs are adept at shedding snow and sleet, which is particularly beneficial in regions with cold temperatures. Their interlocking panels also add an extra layer of wind resistance, minimizing the chances of uplift during storms.

Asphalt Shingles in Variable Weather

Asphalt shingles are used widely due to their ability to handle a range of weather conditions. However, they may not always fare as well under extreme scenarios. When exposed to harsh weather conditions like severe storms or high winds, asphalt shingles can become loose or even tear off. Their performance in cold temperatures can be a concern too, as they can become brittle and more susceptible to damage. For optimal performance, regular maintenance is necessary to ensure that any damaged shingles are quickly replaced to prevent leaks and other weather-related issues.

© 2024 Georgia Roof Advisors. All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy
Privacy Policy
Georgia Roof Advisor Payment Logo